Many debates about MOOCs have been geared towards potential futures. Now, with 5 years experience, let’s focus on what our community achieved. As gurus have left the field and over-expectations have vanished, panelists can now be very concrete about their successes and failures, about their perception of the field as compared to these expectations at the first EMOOCs conference in 2013. I will ask 5 questions to the panelists that I won’t disclose in advance. I invite the audience to send me questions before EMOOCs 2017 simply by an email with subject « 10Q » sent to pierre.dillenbourg@epfl.ch